top of page
Passover 2024 In-Store Pick-Up and Local Delivery Menu
We're not accepting online orders yet. Please contact us to complete the order.
Delivery, Nov 30, 8:45 AM
Delivery & Pickup Menu
Soups, Salads, Appetizers, & Sides
Price per quart (2 servings). We simmer chicken bones for 8 hours to make the stock that goes into it! A whole lot of care goes into this rich, soul-affirming soup. Oh, and the matzo balls? They're floaters!17.49 USD
10.49 USD
18.99 USD
Price per half pound. Our smoked whitefish salad is made with wild-caught whitefish from the great lakes. This is not a mayonnaise salad with some fish byproduct. This is a premium whitefish salad dressed with a little mayonnaise. It tastes like smoke and cold-water fresh fish.19.98 USD
Price per half pound. Made from our rich kippered salmon, this spread is great on a bagel, bialy, or rye bread!19.98 USD
Price per half pound. We're not kidding. It really is seriously great!13.49 USD
Price per half pound. Our pickled herring salad may not be the prettiest salad of the bunch, but surely one of the tastiest! In fact, it serves perfectly as a sweet and sour compliment to our smoked whitefish or baked salmon salads. It's basically a party in your mouth.11.99 USD
Price per half pound. We love pickling fish! And, while pickled herring is our most popular, pickled lox also deserves your attention. We start by desalinating our salty belly lox in fresh water for 3 days, then we pickle it wine vinegar and our own blend of spices. Slightly sweet, it's a great side-dish, appetizer or snack. Feeling luxurious? Order it with some cream sauce and pickled onions.28.99 USD
Priced by the 1/2 lb.28.49 USD
Price per half pound. We gently poach chickens from our friends at Los Paisanos Butcher Shop. We then break apart the pieces, and toss them with pecans, grapes, and celery. It's just a great chicken salad.12.49 USD
Price per half pound. Egg salad can be divisive. You either love it or hate it. We love it. And if you're in that camp, then you'll LOVE ours. It's got little slices of cornichons in it!8.99 USD
Price per half pound. We make our spicy shrimp salad with Kewpie brand Japanese mayo, masago, togarashi and sesame oil.15.49 USD
Price per half pound. Gently steamed and then hand picked, we mix our Canadian lobster with a kiss of mayonnaise and tarragon.23.49 USD
Price per half pound. We sauté chicken livers with onions, then hand-chop them into a chopped liver that walks the line between smooth and chunky. Duck fat, cognac, and hard-cooked eggs round out our chopped liver. It's got that rich unctuousness that makes it an irresistible classic.10.49 USD
Price per half pound. Our vinegar-based cucumber salad is the perfect foil to all of that smoked fish you're ordering! It's no wonder that it's a staple on the appetizing table.8.99 USD
Price by 1/2 lb.8.99 USD
Price per half pound. Macaroni salad is part of the holy trinity of delicatessen salads. In fact, it is the only acceptable form of pasta salad. We make ours with a homemade dressing that has a nice little zing to it!5.99 USD
Price per half pound. Nothing is worse than sad, flavorless coleslaw. Ok, yes, of course, war, famine, illness, they're all worse... But, you get what I'm sayin'. Our coleslaw though is AWESOME!5.99 USD
Price per half pound. I've never met a potato that I didn't like, and potato salad can really never be bad. Well, maybe it can.... But, ours is outstanding!5.99 USD
Price per half pound. "What's health salad?" is a question we often get asked. It's like coleslaw's healthier cousin... Vinegar-based slaw, oregano. A great foil to fatty pastrami.
Size Choic6.49 USD
Price by 1/2 lb.5.49 USD
9.50 USD
9.50 USD
9.50 USD
Latkes & Kugels
Price per latke. Our potato latkes are simple, traditional potato pancakes. They're great with some Grandma Yetta's apple sauce.4.49 USD
24.94 USD
48.99 USD
Price per latke. Celery root adds some complexity to these awesome sweet potato pancakes. They're great when heated up in the oven, but unlike the traditional potato latkes, they're pretty great to eat when they're cold as well! Served best with some creme fraiche!4.49 USD
24.94 USD
$37.99/dozen. Celery root adds some complexity to these awesome sweet potato pancakes. They're great when heated up in the oven, but unlike the traditional potato latkes, they're pretty great to eat when they're cold as well! Served best with some creme fraiche!48.99 USD
5.99 USD
34.99 USD
$49/dozen. Our traditional potato latkes made gluten-free with gluten-free matzo meal (Requires 48 hours advance order).67.99 USD
8oz Tub7.99 USD
Price Per Half Pint10.99 USD
Priced by the half pint5.49 USD
Priced Per One Pint9.99 USD
Roe & Accoutrements
Price per 30g tin. Farmed in California, these firm, medium-size silver eggs have a clean-up front palate with a full-flavored assertive brine to finish. These just might be the best bang for your buck eggs!81.00 USD
Price per 30g tin. Proudly labeled "American Caviar," hackleback sturgeon have made a comeback over the last couple of decades. Their eggs are small, black to dark brown orbs with sweet notes upfront, a light earthiness, and a buttery finish.96.00 USD
Price per 30g tin. A luxurious caviar that will remind you of beluga. These large, dark brown eggs have an assertive mineral flavor on the front with a nutty smooth finish.151.00 USD
Price per 30g tin. Kaluga hybrid sturgeon, produce this exquisite caviar. When you put it in your mouth, you immediately taste a mild buttery note that's even more luxe than the traditional beluga caviar. The finish has similar earthy and nutty tones to Siberian sturgeon.191.00 USD
Price per 30g tin. Our osetra caviar has round, plump grains with a unique, lingering and nutty flavor reminiscent of hazelnuts and fresh walnuts.166.00 USD
Price per 30g tin. Golden osetra, also known as royal caviar is golden yellow in color, abundantly rich, and relatively rare. This caviar is farmed in the Amur river valley, on the Chinese side of the Sino-Russian border. It is exceptional in every way.241.00 USD
Price per 2 oz. jar. These large eggs have a lovely salinity that just pops in your mouth20.99 USD
4 oz jar. Smaller orbs than salmon roe, this trout roe is smooth and earthy26.99 USD
Price per 4 oz jar. Really special stuff, this French trout roe is smoky and the perfect topping to an oyster31.99 USD
Price per pack of 16 blinis12.99 USD
Price per 8 ounce container. Creme fraiche, the richer, French cousin to American sour cream, is a traditional accompaniment to caviar.7.99 USD
Sieved hard-cooked eggs9.99 USD
It's highly advisable to avoid using metal spoons when serving caviar as the metal can react with the caviar causing off-putting flavours. Traditionally, mother of pearl spoons are used instead. Best to buy 1 spoon for each type of caviar you're planning to serve as to avoid mixing flavours.9.99 USD
Price per 1 oz container. Little green eggs from flying fish are infused with the sharp tang of wasabi. They're great on a latke. They're great as a topping for so many things. They're great for clearing your sinuses. - 1 oz.11.99 USD
Smoked & Cured Fish
Price per quarter pound. Silky, rich, and soft with moderate smoke. Don't let the low price fool you. This is one of our favorites!13.49 USD
Price per quarter pound. Rich and assertively flavored, this is the quintessential smoked salmon for a bagel with cream cheese. The standard15.49 USD
Price per quarter pound. This salmon is has an assertive smoke that doesn't overwhelm, and it's relatively firm due to the double curing process. Absolutely awesome!16.49 USD
Price per quarter pound. This slightly firm salmon is mild and silky. Harvested in the cold waters of Scotland, it has a pristinely clean finish.17.49 USD
Price per quarter pound. This salmon is VERY gently smoked. It's super mild, and the most buttery salmon we sell. It's just pure salmon butter.17.49 USD
Price per quarter pound. This is O.G. - the real lox! It's salt-cured and not smoked. Some might call it assertively salty. It's safer to say that it's aggressively salty. We love it. If you like salty stuff, you will too. We can't speak to what your urologist might think. It's awesome on a well-toasted bialy with scallion cream cheese and tomato.15.49 USD
Price per quarter pound. Imagine if smoked salmon and pastrami had a love-child with a lovely lingering peppery bite. This salmon is cured with pastrami spices, smoked, and then rubbed with pastrami rub. It's just a party in your mouth!16.49 USD
Price per quarter pound. Our house-cured gravlax begins with a bath of aquavit and lemon juice. We then cure it slowly with salt, sugar, black pepper and fresh dill. After 3 days, we remove the cure, and pack copious amounts of freshly chopped dill on top of the salmon.15.99 USD
Price per 1/2 lb Insanely Rich and awesome smoked belly strips! SOOOOO GOOD!23.99 USD
Price per quarter pound. This loin center cut of smoked Scottish salmon is pure opulence. Cut thick like sashimi, sliding a piece into your mouth is the gastronomic equivalent of listening to a symphony orchestra play live. Reserved for special occasions, it is beautiful on its own or when paired with caviar, blini, and creme fraiche.26.74 USD
Price per quarter pound.16.74 USD
Price per quarter Pound. Smoked Black Cod. Brined with Garlic and Paprika. Sable is Rich, Fatty and Delicious.22.99 USD
Price per quarter pound. Earthy and rich, smoked sturgeon is among the meatiest fish available! It's great with butter on a bialy Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers23.74 USD
Price per half fish. Choose between the head section, the tail section or the whole fish.41.99 USD
Price per fish. Just like chubbs used to be! Juicy, smoky, and rich. Just a bit bigger!39.99 USD
Price per fish. These trout have an assertive freshwater trout flavor. They're really great flaked over a salad of peppery greens with dijon vinaigrette35.99 USD
Price per pack. All natural and smoky flavours. These fillets are vacuum sealed.16.99 USD
Price per half pound. Rich Scottish salmon, coated with cracked pepper and smoked over fruit woods give this flaky salmon a camp-firey smokiness Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers23.48 USD
Price per half pound. Bluefish, often pejoratively described as "fishy," when smoked over fruit woods, loses those flavours. What replaces them is a deep and profound smoke. Fished, cured, and smoked in Rhode Island, this stuff is just great!23.98 USD
Price per half pound. Bluefish, often pejoratively described as "fishy," when smoked over fruit woods, loses those flavours. What replaces them is a deep and profound smoke. Coated in cracked black pepper, this bluefish is fished, cured, and smoked in Rhode Island, this stuff is just great!23.98 USD
Cream Cheese
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy - the perfect spread for a bagel!8.99 USD
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. We mix it with a whole lot of freshly chopped scallions. It's the perfect spread for a bagel!9.49 USD
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. We then brunoise red, orange, and yellow bell peppers, and combine them with minced fresh garlic, to make some truly remarkable vegetable cream cheese.9.99 USD
Price per half pound. It's garlicky, it’s herby, it’s absolutely BANGIN’!9.99 USD
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. One brave soul on our team, then puts on a pair of goggles and finely grates a whole bunch of horseradish root. That and a healthy pinch of ground white pepper get folded into the cream cheese. Not gonna lie, it's pretty awesome.25.98 USD
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. Then we mix it with Laoganma, A.K.A. spicy chili crisp, A.K.A. angry lady sauce. Sure it's great on a bagel.... Know what else it's great on? A spoon!10.99 USD
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. Ground Nova is whipped into our cream cheese to make this appetizing shop and bagel store classic. As for me? I LOVE it on a poppy seed bagel. But that's me. You do you.12.99 USD
$9.49/half pound. Perfect for vegans and the lactose challenged among us, unlike tofu cream cheese, this Stockeld® cream cheese doesn't taste and look like spackle. In fact, its super tasty!10.49 USD
Price per half pound. Perfect for vegans and the lactose challenged among us, unlike tofu cream cheese, this Stockeld® cream cheese doesn't taste and look like spackle. In fact, it's super tasty!10.99 USD
Herrings
Price per fillet. The Jewish appetizing shop classic done right, Jumbo salted herring filets are desalinated, and then pickled in wine vinegar with spices and a bit of sugar. Choose from herring in wine sauce or herring with cream and onions.4.50 USD
Price per fllet. Large baby herring fillets are salted and pickled with warming spices and beetroot powder giving them a salty and sweet red hue. Great with some cream cheese and pumpernickel bread.6.25 USD
Price per fillet. Schmaltz herring is velvety salted herring, preserved in oil. Think of it as herring confit. Sorta.6.00 USD
Price per fillet. We marinate our classic pickled herring in a homemade whole grain dijon mustard and fresh dill sauce.4.75 USD
Price per rollmop. Our pickled herring pounded thin and wrapped around pickled onions.4.50 USD
Price per rollmop4.50 USD
Holiday Platters (IN-STORE PICK-UP ONLY. NOT AVAILABLE FOR DELIVERY)
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Rich and Smoky Gaspe Nova, hand-sliced and beautifully arranged on a platter with red onions and capers. Served with assorted bagels & bialys along with Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese. (This option DOES NOT include Tomato, cucumber, or Lemon Price Per Person $28.00. Minimum 8 people)225.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Rich and Smoky Gaspe Nova, hand-sliced and beautifully arranged on a platter with red onions, tomato, cucumber, capers and lemons. Served with assorted bagels & bialy, also Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese. (Price Per Person $29.00 Minimum 8 People)233.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Hand-sliced mild Scottish smoked salmon, pastrami-smoked salmon, and house-cured gravlax, beautifully arranged on a platter with thinly sliced red onions and capers. Served with assorted bagels & bialys along with Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese. (This option DOES NOT include Tomato, cucumber, or Lemon. Price Per Person $34.00 Minimum 8 people)273.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Hand-sliced mild Scottish smoked salmon, pastrami-smoked salmon, and house-cured gravlax, beautifully arranged on a platter with thinly sliced red onions and capers. Served with assorted bagels & bialys along with Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese. (Price Per Person $35.00 Minimum 8 people)281.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Rich and Smoky Gaspe Nova, whole filleted Door County, WI smoked whitefish, Sable and Fatty Kippered Salmon beautifully arranged on a platter with red onions and capers. Served with assorted Bagel & Bialys, also Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese (This platter DOES NOT come with Tomato, Cucumber and Lemons) Price Per Person $40.00 Minimum 8 People321.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Rich and Smoky Gaspe Nova, whole filleted Door County, WI smoked whitefish, Sable and Fatty Kippered Salmon beautifully arranged on a platter with red onions, tomatoes, cucumber, lemons and capers. Served with assorted Bagel & Bialys, also Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese (Price Per Person $41.00 Minimum 8 People)329.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Rich and smoky Gaspe Nova, wild Scottish salmon, pastrami-cured salmon, whole filleted Door County, WI smoked whitefish, house-pickled herring with cream or wine sauce and onions, and Fatty Kippered Salmon, beautifully arranged on a platter with red onions and capers. Served with assorted Bagels & Bialys, also Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese. (This platter DOES NOT have tomatoes, cucumbers, and lemons. Price Per Person $45.00 Minimum 8 People)361.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Rich and smoky Gaspe Nova, wild Scottish salmon, pastrami-cured salmon, whole filleted Door County, WI smoked whitefish, house-pickled herring with cream or wine sauce and onions, and Fatty Kippered Salmon, beautifully arranged on a platter with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, lemons and capers. Served with assorted Bagels & Bialys, also Scallion & Plain Cream Cheese. (Price Per Person $46.00 Minimum 8 People)369.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Your choice of 6 of our salads, beautifully arranged on a platter and served with sliced rye and pumpernickel bread, assorted bagels, or both sliced rye/pump and assorted bagels. Please choose 6 of the salads below for your platter.
Price Per Person $25.00. Minimum 8 people201.00 USD
$9/person. Your choice of assorted Shelsky’s Brooklyn Bagels, sliced and arranged on a platter. Served with plain and scallion cream cheese. Please include in the special requests field below, whether you’d like to swap out the plain or the scallion cream cheese.109.00 USD
Your choice of 3 of our classic Jewish deli meats, beautifully arranged on a platter and served with your choice of 2 sides, assorted pickles, sliced rye and pumpernickel, spicy brown deli mustard, and Russian dressing.232.92 USD
Your choice of 4 of our classic Jewish deli meats, beautifully arranged on a platter and served with your choice of 2 sides, assorted pickles, sliced rye and pumpernickel, spicy brown deli mustard, and Russian dressing.256.92 USD
A perfect platter of raw vegetables served with a creamy, herbaceous dip of fromage blanc, mayonnaise, tarragon, parsley, chives, and chervil. (serves 20+)90.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Round out a Shelsky's holiday celebration with our sweets platter. Homemade assorted rugelach, chocolate babka, cinnamon babka (only for platters for more than 12 people), gooey coconut macaroons, honey cake, and chocolate chip cookies with Maldon sea salt flakes. 10 person minimum.151.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Diced fresh fruit beautifully arranged on a 12" platter. (serves 10-12)70.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Diced fresh fruit beautifully arranged on a 16" platter. (serves 15-25)95.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Diced fresh fruit beautifully arranged on a 18" platter. (serves 30-40)120.00 USD
Desserts
Price per Raspberry Hanukkah jelly donuts5.00 USD
Price per half pound (About 4 pieces). We make the best rugelach in NYC. No, seriously. We combine great dark chocolate and wild-lingonberry preserves to make the lovely filling for these moist, cream cheese dough rugelach.10.99 USD
Price per half pound (about 4 pieces). Our rugelach are the vey best in NYC. I'm sorry, Miss Jackson. I am for real! We make our rapricot and walnut filling in house and stuff enough into our cream cheese dough to make a rugelach that is the furthest thing from dry. They rock!10.99 USD
Price per half pound (about 4 pieces). Our rugelach are the vey best in NYC. No kidding! We make our raspberry and walnut filling in house and stuff enough into our cream cheese dough to make a rugelach that is the furthest thing from dry. They rock!10.99 USD
Price per half pound (about 4 pieces). My Daughters names are Clementine and Ginger. And, they get along so well, that I thought that maybe their eponymous foods might also work beautifully together. Well, as it turns out, I was right. Give 'em a shot. You'll keep coming back for them!10.99 USD
Priced per dozen26.99 USD
Priced per dozen30.99 USD
Seriously. This is the best traditional chocolate babka in all of New York.23.00 USD
Imagine a cinnamon roll... in Jewish form.23.00 USD
Two Pound Loaf23.00 USD
Priced by the single blintz, these fresh farmer cheese filled blintzes are substantial. We serve them with a blueberry and cream soda compote. Sounds nuts. I know. But trust me on this!6.99 USD
Our overfilled creamy farmer cheese blintzes served with blueberry and cream soda compote. Sounds nuts. I know. But for real... It's awesome. Trust me on this one.65.99 USD
Priced per cookie3.00 USD
Priced per cookie3.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Round out a Shelsky's holiday celebration with our sweets platter. Homemade assorted rugelach, chocolate babka, cinnamon babka (only for platters for more than 12 people), gooey coconut macaroons, honey cake, and chocolate chip cookies with Maldon sea salt flakes. 10 person minimum.151.00 USD
Salad of fresh fruit (serves 6-8)44.99 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Diced fresh fruit beautifully arranged on a 12" platter. (serves 10-12)70.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Diced fresh fruit beautifully arranged on a 16" platter. (serves 15-25)95.00 USD
Orders with platters are NOT available for delivery. You must pick-up any order with a platter.
Diced fresh fruit beautifully arranged on a 18" platter. (serves 30-40)120.00 USD
New wt 9 oz9.99 USD
New wt 9 oz9.99 USD
Gelt & Candles
Price of Bag of Four1.99 USD
Box of 24 Bags42.99 USD
Bag of 4 Gelt1.99 USD
Box of 24 Bags42.99 USD
11.99 USD
1/2 lb (8oz box) Dark Chocolate, assorted nuts and fruits, flax, sunflower, chia seeds, coconut, spices and grey sea salt.25.99 USD
Price Set For One Box6.99 USD
For those that want to jazz up their Hanukkah celebrations with some fancier candles… These beauties are for you!15.99 USD
My Mom always had these honeycomb candles in our Menorah. They’re great looking, burn slowly, burn neatly, and the wax is malleable so you can squeeze them into the tiny holes easily on your Menorah.18.99 USD
1.99 USD
4.49 USD
Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
3.50 USD
1.99 USD
1.99 USD
These gluten-free bagels actually taste like bagels! They're chewy and everything!4.99 USD
These gluten-free bagels actually taste like bagels! They're chewy and everything!4.99 USD
These gluten-free bagels actually taste like bagels! They're chewy and everything!4.99 USD
Delicatessen Meats and Breads
Price per half pound. Brined then rubbed with a special blend of classic pastrami spices, our pastrami is made from the fatty beef navel, and it is slowly smoked and then steamed to tender rich awesomeness.18.99 USD
Price per half pound. Our briskets are corned with a special blend of spices. A bit leaner than pastrami, the flavor is clean with that nostalgic, jewish deli somethin' somethin'!18.49 USD
Price per half pound. Sometimes you're just in the mood for some juicy roasted turkey. Our turkey breasts are brined gently and crazy juicy. We slice them thinly.18.49 USD
Price per half pound. We brine Dellapietra's rounds for 3 days before dusting them with lots of black pepper and slowly roasting them to a beautiful, rosy, pink medium-rare. We slice it thinly to order.18.49 USD
Price per half pound. Our beef tongues spend 4 days hanging out in a brine of classic pickling spices. It is then simmered gently for 4 hours. We slice it thinly, and it's absolutely amazing served either hot or cold.18.99 USD
Plain, a.k.a. Unseeded rye never gets the love it deserves. People associate rye bread with the assertive anise-like flavor of caraway seeds, and while that flavor is classic new York, it can turn some people off from the joys of rye bread. Well, we are going to change all that5.00 USD
When you think about Jewish rye bread, this is the subject of your dreams5.00 USD
This soft, sliced pumpernickel bread from Rockland bakery is a thing of perfection. Their famous rye bread, touched by molasses, lending its characteristic deep brown color and notes of complex caramel5.00 USD
Price per 2-pack. These are just a New York classic. The perfect onion rolls. Baked by our friends at Orwasher's Bakery.5.00 USD
bottom of page